Tony L
Administrator
“The International Court of Justice rules that Israel must halt its military offensive in Rafah in southern Gaza” BBC.
What will happen if they don't comply?“The International Court of Justice rules that Israel must halt its military offensive in Rafah in southern Gaza” BBC.
Hamas could call their bluff and release the remaining 'hostages' but I doubt that would have any effect either. It might not be a bad tactic, who knows. The longer Israel fights the more they will kill - negotiation really is the best option (as we saw previously) if your goal is actually to free the hostages. All such efforts to date have been scuppered by Netanyahu and his cabinet. The stumbling block is a permanent ceasefire. Why should that that be a problem if you have your people back, unless...Much and all as the court's decision is a symbolic victory, I'm sceptical that the ruling will make one iota of difference really alas.
No doubt the Likud crew will reference the court's comments about the need for immediate release of the Israeli hostages, and cite failure to do that as justifiable grounds for ignoring the ruling:
Judge Salam also spoke about the situation of Israeli hostages who are still being held by Hamas in Gaza.
"The court expresses grave concern over the fate of the hostages... and calls for their immediate and unconditional release," he tells the court.
"We find it deeply troubling that many still remain in captivity," he adds.
Perhaps read posts 9264 and 5?I've been reading the reports on the Hague Court's statement. It calls on Israel to halt its offensive in Gaza, which of course is a good idea. But it also calls for the "immediate and unconditional release" of Israeli hostages held by Hamas.
Oddly, this part of their statement has been ignored on this thread.
I may be wrong, of course, but I think the release of the hostages would almost automatically cause Israel to call off its Rafah offensive.
Oh really! All the commentators say that Israel has rejected that kind of settlement at every turn...I may be wrong, of course, but I think the release of the hostages would almost automatically cause Israel to call off its Rafah offensive.
Nonsense. Netanyahu can’t divert now. If all the hostages were released now, he’d have to find another reason to continue his massacres.I've been reading the reports on the Hague Court's statement. It calls on Israel to halt its offensive in Gaza, which of course is a good idea. But it also calls for the "immediate and unconditional release" of Israeli hostages held by Hamas.
Oddly, this part of their statement has been ignored on this thread.
I may be wrong, of course, but I think the release of the hostages would almost automatically cause Israel to call off its Rafah offensive.
I don't think it is quite that simple:Oh really! All the commentators say that Israel has rejected that kind of settlement at every turn...
Netanyahu has been clear that his objective is the elimination of Hamas.I may be wrong, of course, but I think the release of the hostages would almost automatically cause Israel to call off its Rafah offensive.
Netanyahu has been clear that his objective is the elimination of Hamas.
Last time that happened, the IDF shot the hostages. An absolute tragedy, but a sign of the chaotic situation that's there. As I said, the only winners are the leaders of Hamas, safe in their Qatari hotel suites...Wonder what would happen if Hamas sent hostages out with a white flag to avoid getting their own people killed?
Yes, just as Hamas, in harmony with its backer Iran, has made it clear that its objective is the elimination of Israel. But they will have to come to terms under international pressure, and a first step would be a return of the hostage by Hamas, and a ceasefire by Israel (and by Hamas). Talks can then proceed, guided by international support by both the West and the Arab countries that want a peaceful settlement rather than continued carnage.Netanyahu has been clear that his objective is the elimination of Hamas.
I agree with your first points, but how is a peaceful settlement even possible without a Palestinian State and a return of seized Palestinian land in the West Bank, neither of which Israel will ever agree to under current support they receive from the US, UK and other allies. This will only change if these enabling countries exert massive economic and political pressure which of course will never happen.Yes, just as Hamas, in harmony with its backer Iran, has made it clear that its objective is the elimination of Israel. But they will have to come to terms under international pressure, and a first step would be a return of the hostage by Hamas, and a ceasefire by Israel (and by Hamas). Talks can then proceed, guided by international support by both the West and the Arab countries that want a peaceful settlement rather than continued carnage.
Not chaotic. IDF thought they were shooting Palestinians with a white flag. Disgusting.Last time that happened, the IDF shot the hostages. An absolute tragedy, but a sign of the chaotic situation that's there. As I said, the only winners are the leaders of Hamas, safe in their Qatari hotel suites...