Having had the bike up on the stand, I can now see that there is some frame damage, and the fork is very bent. I have agreed a figure with the driver on the basis of replacement cost which both of us are happy with.
For Andrew's tyres, Gatorskins are the toughest, most puncture proof tyres I would consider for a normal road bike (Schwalbe Marathon Plus being very heavy, only in wider sizes, and more for hybrids or serious touring), but they do affect the feel of the bike and have high rolling resistance for a road tyre. When I ran them, I did occasionally still get punctures: on average once every few thousand miles, riding mostly roads and cycle tracks. But that's very good, I think. 4 Seasons (I guess that's what you mean) are not quite as extreme -- the next step down. 4000s have a reasonable amount of puncture protection, but major on being a fast, everyday, tyre.
If you would prefer something between 4 Seasons and 4000s, consider the Grand Prix GT. It's what I'd been running for the last few months on Toby. A lot nicer feel than Gatorskins. From what others say, it seems they are close to the All Seasons in toughness, but have significantly better rolling resistance -- closer to the 4000s in that respect. One of the pair I got was incredibly hard to fit though (the only puncture I've had with them was from the original fitting because I got a bit carried away), but that's the only downside I could find. I got them for about £25 each, which is fair.
Bike tyre comparison site:
https://www.bicyclerollingresistance.com/ Unfortunately, doesn't list the Grand Prix GT, but has the other three.
Kind regards
- Garry