advertisement


Naim: Is it personal?

You have caught my interest, what made the Mana forum like the "Wild West"?

It was totally unregulated which brought out the worst in people. The idea that people are fundamentally reasonable and good turned out to be untrue. It was nuts!
 
It was totally unregulated which brought out the worst in people. The idea that people are fundamentally reasonable and good turned out to be untrue. It was nuts!
Yeah, ISTR one bloke who went so far as to tear up his living room floorboards and install foundational footers for his Mana stacks. (not necessarily a bad idea, mind)

acc27b38af95dbca0fcf904ee87602c4.jpg
 
Last edited:
Because I believed what the dealer told me, that it was going to be a massive upgrade, he fitted it for free and by the time I'd got it home it was (a) rather too late and (b) if you take it back as a 20-something and say it's not as good as the old worn out cartridge you're going to get a load of patronising bullshht about the rest of the system isn't up to it, you don't know how to lisyen, etc, so you persuade yourself it's better. It's exactly how free cable returns work and it works a treat.
Perhaps you have forgotten how patronising an environment 80s and 90s hifi shops were, and how intimidating. To this day I still remember some tosser in a Sevenoaks somewhere near leatherhead sneering at me when I expressed an interest in a Gyrodec in the window at about £700. "Right. What are you currently listening to? A Regs 2? It's probably too big a step up, I wouldn't recommend it for you. " Wxxker. His loss, I had the money in the bank and if he'd given me a demo I would almost certainly have carried it out of the shop. I had too many experiences like that, and if that's hifi shops then I don't mourn their passing.
This one never gets tired...

 
What we're gonna do right here is go back, way back, back into time, when the only people that existed were troglodytes — cave men, cave women, Neanderthal, troglodytes.

Let's take the average cave man at home, listening to his stereo.

Sometimes he'd get up, try to do his thing. He'd begin to move, something like this ... dance...dance.


Thems were the days.

Joe
 
Because I believed what the dealer told me, that it was going to be a massive upgrade, he fitted it for free and by the time I'd got it home it was (a) rather too late and (b) if you take it back as a 20-something and say it's not as good as the old worn out cartridge you're going to get a load of patronising bullshht about the rest of the system isn't up to it, you don't know how to lisyen, etc, so you persuade yourself it's better. It's exactly how free cable returns work and it works a treat.
Perhaps you have forgotten how patronising an environment 80s and 90s hifi shops were, and how intimidating. To this day I still remember some tosser in a Sevenoaks somewhere near leatherhead sneering at me when I expressed an interest in a Gyrodec in the window at about £700. "Right. What are you currently listening to? A Regs 2? It's probably too big a step up, I wouldn't recommend it for you. " Wxxker. His loss, I had the money in the bank and if he'd given me a demo I would almost certainly have carried it out of the shop. I had too many experiences like that, and if that's hifi shops then I don't mourn their passing.

I just went around until I found a shop that wasn’t like that. Audio Counsel in Oldham. How hard can it be? I am actually shocked you could be swayed by the hard sell tactics as you seem to be so accomplished in everything else including using bilinguality as a barometer of how much more of a ‘world player’ you are than someone like me :D
 
The individual who started me on my hi-fi journey back in my mid-teens had a full rack of Naim gear. As I'm now in my early 50's, I can't possibly remember which Naim models were in play. They drove a set of Linn Isobariks, with a Sondek LP-12 as his front end. A very fine sounding system at the time which really impressed me, coming from a mid-fi background. As his tastes evolved over the next few years, he began moving toward vacuum tubes (valves), and rest was history (for both of us). I haven't used a solid-state amplifier in over 25 years.

My anti solid-state biases aside, I always felt like Naim were simply a pain in the ass to be blunt. BNC connectors on audio? DIN connectors to supply power from various ridiculously named boxes? Numptys, humpties, burndys, etc? Stiff speaker cable that looked as if were better suited to an arc welder? Nah - you had to really drink the Kool-Aid and commit. Glad I didn't.

What was this all about anyway? Seemed so unnecessary
 
I just went around until I found a shop that wasn’t like that. Audio Counsel in Oldham. How hard can it be? I am actually shocked you could be swayed by the hard sell tactics as you seem to be so accomplished in everything else including using bilinguality as a barometer of how much more of a ‘world player’ you are than someone like me :D
I went round and didn't find a shop like that. How hard could it be? Quite hard, clearly. As far as being a "world player" I don't consider myself as such, but I know better than to nitpick someone else's grammar in a second language, and I'm actually shocked that a man of the world like you apparently doesn't. :)
 
I can’t even remember the competition, but when my Arcam Alpha 5 died I auditioned a few machines but the Naim 5i just sounded much better than anything else I auditioned, even if it was above my budget. I then swapped a Linn Intek for a NAP 150/ NAC 112 and never looked back, building my way up to 282/ Hicap/ 250. When the times comes to replace I will most likely buy something more moderately priced, but for the time being it does me and I enjoy it very much. I don’t really understand PRAT, flat earth etc and I’m not that interested. I just know I like the sound of my current system.
 
Later on with Adam as moderator (correct name ?) that forum was entirely different and almost free speech as opposite to current highly moderated marketing tool for the Sheep brigade.

It’s intolerable now. I left a few years ago and don’t miss it at all. There used to be quite a bunch of characters posting, I have the very occasional lurk but it’s just completely bland and uninteresting now.
 
I’m sure that not everyone is in love with Naim around here but I’m just curious to know as to why so many people have an intense dislike of the “brand” . I cannot think of any other Hifi company that divides opinion in such a scale.

'Cultism' gets to me for some reason (maybe my Catholic upbringing?).

It's not just Naim, Audio Note, Chord, Harbeth and Linn also have a similar approach.
 
I’m sure that not everyone is in love with Naim around here but I’m just curious to know as to why so many people have an intense dislike of the “brand” . I cannot think of any other Hifi company that divides opinion in such a scale.

My 2 cents. I enjoyed and probably still do enjoy the Naim sound. I will honestly hand that to them without hesitation. But, the company executives and various representatives are literally insufferable, except for Jason Gould. But they aren't as bad as the Design and Engineering team, who are smoking the really good stuff.

For example, their wonky engineering voodoo beliefs about DIN connections, mystical earthing design, always imminent Sword of Damocles RECAPPING holy grail obligations, the endless PSU upgrade path to empty your pockets further while proving that they should've designed proper power supplies in their units in the first place (like practically every other manufacturer on the planet), the mysterious admonitions about proper cable dressing, the unethical and wasteful requirement to leave their units powered up 24/7 in spite of eco-concerns, worldwide inflation and skyrocketing electricity costs, the unnatural, illogical and most probably ill-fated marriage with Focal, under the Vervent Audio holding structure, which gives way to a sonic nightmare of epic proportions and the incessant Marketing propaganda that suggests the opposite was a bit much for me.

There are two remaining straws that finally broke the camel's back:
1. Naim has always erroneously and dishonestly insisted that their cheapo ALPS Blue Velvet potentiometer implementations, which are systematically skewed off-balance, be it for volume of balance control on the integrateds and preamps, are "the best possible" because Steve Sells declared "they sound better". What a load of cr@p. I even had a major retailer tell me that if there is the (typical) imbalance then "you aren't using it as intended". LOL, obviously.
2. Probably the worst yet is the Naim forum and the Chinese-style censorship that is routinely practiced there. This is a well-known fact far and wide to both Naim users and non-Naim users. Free speech on internet forums does require some moderation, but an all-out metamorphosis into gigantic propaganda machine where only monolithic inputs conforming to the Party line are tolerated has turned theirs into a vast wasteland of self-congratulating fanboys.

So, not necessarily hating on Naim, just calling out things as they are. Your experience may be different.
 
I just never understood why people have got fleeced by dealers and bought kit they don't like. You're in the hands of a salesman. Never used a dealer, never will.

Naim just seems to me like people can't be bothered to do their own research, pick up what hifi and go ooh that's good.
 
I went round and didn't find a shop like that. How hard could it be? Quite hard, clearly. As far as being a "world player" I don't consider myself as such, but I know better than to nitpick someone else's grammar in a second language, and I'm actually shocked that a man of the world like you apparently doesn't. :)
Not really a case of knowing better, in my eyes he’s been a persistent troll on these Naim threads so sod him frankly and if that makes me a twat then fine.
 
Perhaps you have forgotten how patronising an environment 80s and 90s hifi shops were, and how intimidating. To this day I still remember some tosser in a Sevenoaks somewhere near leatherhead sneering at me when I expressed an interest in a Gyrodec in the window at about £700. "Right. What are you currently listening to? A Regs 2? It's probably too big a step up, I wouldn't recommend it for you. " Wxxker. His loss, I had the money in the bank and if he'd given me a demo I would almost certainly have carried it out of the shop. I had too many experiences like that, and if that's hifi shops then I don't mourn their passing.


There was a particularly bad one in Hull in the early 1980s, complete (as I remember) with smug, patronising, unpleasant bloke in cords with a perm. I eventually found my way to a much better one who happened to be a Linn+Naim dealer. Completely different; a lovely approachable chap who even suggested that I measured and copied some Linn stands when I mentioned that I was thinking of making some. Night and day. Both disappeared in the end, however.
 


advertisement


Back
Top