I currently have two versions of this classic recording in my collection - the Australian black CD release on Sony/Columbia from 2004, and the Jazz Wax Records JWR 4525 Direct Metal Mastering 180 gram LP from 2010. It's absolutely stunning how much better the LP is than the CD. Comparatively, the CD sounds two-dimensional and like the instruments are made of cardboard. The LP sounds rich and dimensional, and particularly on the intro to "Strange Meadow Lark," Dave's piano sounds as if it could have been recorded yesterday. There's a little more tape hiss on the LP, but there's also a better sense of space between the instruments, and the bass is tighter / more solid.
I was under the impression that the Australian black CD releases were supposed to be top quality, but I'm a bit disappointed there. Is there a better CD release that I'm missing out on? Heck, is there a better LP release that I'm missing out on? I'd prefer not to go chasing down some impossibly rare and expensive 45 RPM pressing, but short of that, which are your favorites that are available now?
I was under the impression that the Australian black CD releases were supposed to be top quality, but I'm a bit disappointed there. Is there a better CD release that I'm missing out on? Heck, is there a better LP release that I'm missing out on? I'd prefer not to go chasing down some impossibly rare and expensive 45 RPM pressing, but short of that, which are your favorites that are available now?