I have a non corner braced 1981 plinth/ top plate and original base board with a majik sub-chassis, Karousel and lingo 4; have decided to get a new cherry plinth with top plate and base board (fixed or otherwise), a kore and get my Ittok upgraded with new bearings and a rewire.
It’s interesting that you noticed a sound quality change going from an old to new plinth - can you remember how it changed? Thanks
I’ll do my best…
IIRC , big and/or fast bass stuff was less vague (and so more effective and pacy). Taking my speakers off spikes and putting Gaias between them and my bouncy wooden floor had a cruder effect, but not a wholly dissimilar one.
There was a real but less obvious improvement in (say) Joan Baez’s highest bits - the stereo image stayed cleaner and higher-pitched voices, strings and woodwind all tended to get sweet (if you see what I mean) only when appropriate, not (when compared to CD) applying some degree or other of the same tint to lots of different music.
Add a bit more of both effects to a reduction in the sort of background noise that you only notice when it leaves (and makes more detail audible) and you have my best stab at what a Stiletto sounds like. The foot doesn’t tap any less and conversations still get broken up by sudden musical distraction- just as they should - but the proportion of your favourite music that is a bit clearer AND a bit more enjoyable on vinyl goes up.
if you regard the pre-Cirkus and Valhalla sound as what you buy an LP12 for, Karousel, Keel and Radikal may all be be equally pointless. In that case, my guess is that a better damped plinth (with corner bracing?) could still be an improvement, but not a dramatic one (unless your plinth is a bit wonky or the feet a bit knackered). You might not like it any more at all.
If instead you want to keep what an LP12 does, and a Gyrodek or Technics doesn’t quite do, but you also want less noise, less bass bias, better stereo image, cleaner and faster bass when it is on the vinyl and so on, I still wouldn’t change my plinth without first at least thinking about sub-chassis, power supply and bearing. However, if you have got those things just how you want them, a change of plinth can make sense too.
Otoh, even if it didn’t sound 0.01% better, there are a lot of beautiful plinths out there. I’d have no shame changing a plinth just because looking at the new one pleased me.
In your case, the fact you have Karousel and Lingo 4 (both excellent imho) suggests that what you want from an upgrade is pretty similar to what I wanted a while ago. What is more, the lack of corner braces would encourage me to change - a lot of older and unbraced plinths are a fraction smaller as I understand it (making some possible future changes problematic at best) and they can warp fractionally (my first black ash one was by the end a couple mm off square just from time in a living room.