Hi Martin, I just got a RD11s TT last week, I found that the motor and resistor were changed and now are Allied Motion 110V 50Hz motor (9904 111 31813) and 5W 6ohm 8J resistor. Does my resistor is correct to use?
Or I should go back to 10k resistor?
Whomever replaced the motor went with the standard 6k8 (6800 Ohm) as suggested within the motor datasheet. This recommendation is meant to have the motor operate at circa 110V on circa 230V. Most turntable makers run resistor and/or capacitor values that take the mains down to less than 100V. Rega, for example, started out using 15k for both the UK and Europe (same value as in the early RD11/LP12 electrics pic posted by
@cre009 in post #4), later changed to 12k UK and 10k Europe; these before going over to using a second 0.22uF X2 rated metal film capacitor as voltage filter in place of the power dropper resistor. Since sometime during the late 90s Rega have taken to combining capacitor and resistor as voltage dropper; with the P3 2000 PCB having 2 x capacitors and 3 x resistors on (as did the circuit included within the original 110V Planar 3 Upgrade Kit).
Reduced voltage equates to less motor vibration, that is, as long as the phase capacitor remains capable of doing a reasonable job of approaching a 90º phase shift between the feeds to each motor coil. If Allied Motion had bothered to include the 2nd page of the McLennan datasheet, the person who did this motor/resistor swap out would likely have considered the following...
"The optimum torque provided by the motor should only be sufficient to accelerate the platter to synchronous speed, since the lower the motor torque is during fixed speed operation, the lower the vibration inducing torque ripple will be.
For a given installation it may be possible to increase the value of the series resistor ( nominally 6.8 Ohms ) [Ed: should be kOhms] in the basic circuit to optimise motor performance while a lower value of the phasing capacitor ( nominally 0.22 μF ) may prove beneficial. For optimum results trimmers may be added in series with each motor coil to electrically balance the motor."
FYI, with the anniversary Planar 25 Rega fit 0.2uF (via parallel connecting 2 x 0.1uF) as phase cap and fit 2 x 10k pots for hand trimming for lowest vibration (i.e. bare motor actually in hand whilst twiddling these pots). I'm not sure what the voltage drop is before pots with these yet, as they were well into using capacitors as voltage filters. Regardless, as P25 preceded P3 2000, I suspect that the voltages (to each phase) that delivered lowest vibration with P25 were used to determine the fixed capacitors/resistors mix for P3 2000 (and Planar 2/3 Motor Upgrade Kit).
In conclusion, a lot can be learned from looking at these various PCBs/circuits, not to mention that the old 6-way terminal block of RD11/early LP12 makes for a great test platform.