I was at Glyndebourne yesterday, for their production of Debussy’s Pelléas et Mélisande, with Christina Gansch as Mélisande, John Chest as Pelléas, and Christopher Purves as Golaud, with the London Philharmonic Orchestra under Robin Ticciati.
The singers and orchestra were very good (not outstanding), but what really stood out was the at times bizarre production by the Norwegian Stefan Herheim. Some elements worked exceptionally well - in the centre of the stage was a space that rose and fell, changing from being a pool, to the ocean, to an altar, to a dining table, a death-bed, and so on. At the very start, a figure descended into this space, clutching the space above him. This is nowhere in Debussy’s stage directions, and I took it to prefigure Golaud’s descent from jealousy to murderous rage. Many of the stage directions deepened the text - Golaud enmeshed with Pelléas et Mélisande as they met for the last time, emphasising the psychological torture he suffers, and even two Mélisandes on stage at one time, one being the dying physical body and the other the escaping soul. But other elements were odd and unfathomable - a figure of Christ appearing with a lamb draped across his shoulders elicited laughter, rather than deepening the symbolism of the libretto. Similarly, Golaud’s assault of Yniold was crude and unnecessary, and highlighted the main weakness of the production, in that the coup de foudre between Pelléas and Mélisande was understated, and Golaud was in a jealous rage from early on, rather than moving from confusion and disbelief towards the jealousy and rage that leads him to murder Pelléas. This is the backbone of the opera, and if weakened, odd symbols and artefacts introduced into the production don’t compensate.
I know the opera fairly well - alongside Wagner's and Janacek’s operas, I listen to this probably 3 or 4 times a year, and on balance I was rather underwhelmed by the production, while very much enjoying the singing and orchestra. Has anyone else seen this - if so, what did you think? This was my first time at Glyndebourne - what a wonderful place - and hopefully we will be able to return next year.