Advertisement



  1. Things you need to know about the new ‘Conversations’ PM system:

    a) DO NOT REPLY TO THE NOTIFICATION EMAIL! I get them, not the intended recipient. I get a lot of them and I do not want them! It is just a notification, log into the site and reply from there.

    b) To delete old conversations use the ‘Leave conversation’ option. This is just delete by another name.
    Dismiss Notice

Ukraine V

Discussion in 'off topic' started by DimitryZ, Jun 29, 2022.

  1. DonQuixote99

    DonQuixote99 pfm Member

    "Moscow" was criticized, so you hurried to point out that the US was 'famous' for the same fault. Why?
     
  2. kensalriser

    kensalriser pfm Member

    The Great Satan is the source of all known evil. Surely you know that.
     
  3. George J

    George J Herefordshire member

    If one is a defence lawyer one can easily see why this deceptive language is useful. But deceptive it remains, and actually it is dissembling in reality. Glossing something illegal with a soft view of the perpetrator ... Politicians, lawyers and propaganda ministries love dissembling like this if it helps those without critical thinking skills accept the message, prima face.

    George
     
  4. awkwardbydesign

    awkwardbydesign Officially Awesome

    Are you saying that US foreign policy ISN'T especially bad?
     
    ks.234 likes this.
  5. droodzilla

    droodzilla pfm Member

    Did you miss the articles this weekend celebrating the 20th anniversary of the invasion of Iraq, and the peace and prosperity it brought to the region?
     
    anubisgrau and ks.234 like this.
  6. Bart

    Bart pfm Member

    You see what you see - and you’re welcome to it.
     
  7. awkwardbydesign

    awkwardbydesign Officially Awesome

    No. Have you replied to the wrong person?
     
    anubisgrau likes this.
  8. Hook

    Hook Blackbeard's former bo'sun.

    IMHO, too many posts on this thread are being made simply to provoke a reaction.

    Can anyone show me where someone here has argued that the US invasion of Iraq was a good thing? Closest to that I’ve heard was that Saddam was evil, and that most Iraqis should be better off without him. But it is obvious to all by now that destroying Saddam’s military led to chaos, the rise of ISIS, and so on. Have not heard anyone here argue retrospectively that it was a success. It was clearly a failure on many levels. Hundreds of thousands died because of it, and US soldiers/contractors committed war crimes. These are indisputable facts.

    That said, does anyone here think, given the horrible track record, that the US should not have provided military aid to Ukraine? Is anyone arguing that it should all stop now? Is anyone here arguing that a GOP-led, isolationist US would be somehow better for the world? Funny, but I haven’t heard anyone here arguing for any of that. Possible that’s what some here believe, but I haven’t seen any posts actually saying it out loud.

    If someone would like to criticize what the US is doing for Ukraine today, I’m all ears. But what has constantly returning to Afghanistan, Iraq and/or Vietnam actually contributed to the conversation? I am not saying shut up, don’t do it. Feel free to try and continue provoking reactions. Most will ignore, but some will probably take the bait. But it would be really nice if every once in a while, those making references to the past would explain how, specifically, they inform the discussion of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and what different path they suggest we should take. Otherwise, it all comes across as knee-jerk whataboutism. So again, I ask, what exactly would you like see the US change in terms of today’s support of Ukraine?

    To my mind, the really big issue is whether or not the military aid continues after the 2024 election. If the GOP wins back the Presidency, what will happen in Ukraine? What will happen to NATO? Will Western Europe ramp up their military support, or will they abandon Ukraine? I don’t know, but I can think of at least one little Russian despot who is betting on the latter.
     
    flatpopely, Ian G, Plink and 9 others like this.
  9. DimitryZ

    DimitryZ pfm Member

    One should pause to consider Iraq continuously under Saddam and after his passing under his nice sons all the way to today.

    I am pretty sure you would be mum on the numerous attrocities committed by them in the last 20 years. After all this would be native attrocities - nothing European intellectuals historically cared about.
     
  10. ks.234

    ks.234 Half way to Infinity

    The choices were not binary. Containment of Saddam was also an option.
     
    anubisgrau likes this.
  11. DimitryZ

    DimitryZ pfm Member

    Sure, but that never stopped him from mass atrocities against his own population before. His sons, by all reports raised to be fine torturers and rapists, would have been a fitting and natural follow up.

    Morality of nation's actions and historical outcomes are very loosely related, if at all.

    Consider the historical arc where Putin took Ukraine in a week like he planned and successfully forced NATO back to 1997 lines. I guarantee there would have been no ICC indictment of Putin, Taiwan would be negotiating a surrender to China and you would be out front demanding a peace deal now.

    The future would have belonged to Xi, Putin, Jong-un and Khamenei, with our frayed democracies in a historic retreat and our own populations voting for Trumps, Johnsons and further curtailment of our freedoms. That future would certainly reflect on the great victory against the West very positively - it would be celebrated worldwide as the "final death of Western imperialism and the rise of true people's democracy."
     
    Last edited: Mar 19, 2023
  12. DonQuixote99

    DonQuixote99 pfm Member

    You stand by that even if the car was indeed stolen by three 16-year-olds for the thrill of it?
     
  13. George J

    George J Herefordshire member

    Absolutely.

    Just the same as four year old boys ripping the wings off flies. Terrible and they need teaching the wrongness of their ways rather than being soft on their behaviour in so called empathetic and dissembling language.

    The road to Hell is paved with good intent. Sometimes one has to be tough to be kind.

    Just a thought.

    Best wishes from George
     
  14. droodzilla

    droodzilla pfm Member

    Nope. I condemn all murderous thugs. Including Putin and Saddam.

    Also, W and Blair - the blood of hundreds of thousands of innocent ccivilians on their hands.

    My position is not hard to understand.
     
    ks.234 likes this.
  15. droodzilla

    droodzilla pfm Member

    Wrong again.

    I despise all bullies and authoritarians including Putin.

    And Trump and Johnson.

    My position is entirely clear and morally consistent.
     
    ks.234 likes this.
  16. DimitryZ

    DimitryZ pfm Member

    I am sure that you consider your position to be clear and morally consistent.

    However, when I tried to get you to articulate any practical position earlier, your response was "I dunno."

    So do you now have an actual position re. topic of this thread (other than US is BAD) that you are willing to share with the thread?
     
    Last edited: Mar 19, 2023
  17. anubisgrau

    anubisgrau pfm Member


    You can't beat

    "Noble Anvil"

    For NATO bombing of Yugoslavia in 1999.
     
  18. DimitryZ

    DimitryZ pfm Member

    I don't think "Yugoslavia" existed in 1999 and its very fine people have been killing each other for a decade with much abandon.

    I would have thought Milosevic had some excellent names for his ethnic cleansing operations.
     
    George J likes this.
  19. ks.234

    ks.234 Half way to Infinity

    Because the criticism of Moscow as the sole user of euphemisms is not true. The truth is that the US is famous for the same fault. The demand that moral judgements are ring fenced to exclude comparisons is not moral
     
  20. ks.234

    ks.234 Half way to Infinity

    That’s a silly projection. Nobody said that.
     

Share This Page





Advertisement


  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice