Major retread of previous posts of mine, but casual opamp swaps are a minefield.
Fitting an IC socket and swapping opamps appears a nice easy usually fairly benign way to play. BUT I think most of the time what you are playing with isn't the difference between opamps, but the difference between opamp susceptibilities in the circuit you are experimenting within, which get folded into the audio as audible, if subtle, differences. These are very real, and may make for audible diferences where on paper there should be none.
For example - an opamp that has high bandwidth or very high open-loop output impedance or restricted output drive current could be poor choices in a filter circuit, or wherever the load is capacitative. A circuit with a noisy raw supply could easily sound better with a 'worse' (slow, low-bandwidth) opamp with great PSRR than a 'better' opamp with poor PSRR.. and so on and so on. Remember every pin on an opamp is effectively an input!
The OP627 has a very large GBw. As such it is inordinately sensitive to decoupling arrangements and similar precise implementation details. As a result even using it in IC sockets is a a 'NO' for halfway-good results.. . likewise the Ad8065, the LM6172 and similar 'must haves'. 10-Mhz+ GBW opamps in sockets is just asking for trouble; that 'great treble' is probably the result of major HF unhappiness.
Conversely, the 5532/34 measures well, but it is also very tolerant of less-than-perfect implementation.Reliable, if not the last-2% word. But very reliable. So which would you rather have?
This is why I don't recommend any generic swaps anymore - leave the opamp be, get the circuit working as well as you can via attention to PSU and layout and maybe passive parts replacement, and then - only if you must - try rolling opamps. And then be prepared to work at it. Either way you may be surprised how little there is to be gained when other problems are 'fixed'!