If a picture paints a thousand words, this summarises well what I've been doing this afternoon.
O-rings and stethoscope by
Michael Pickwell, on Flickr
Since my last post I've been niggled by the feeling that I could/should be able to get the noise floor of the TD124 lower still.
After some investigation with a mechanics stethoscope I came to the conclusion that the brand new Audio Silente idler was responsible for quite a lot of the noise.
I popped the original idler back on and sure enough it was quieter. Hmmm.
The Audio Silente idler comes in a pack with a selection of four different o-rings to use; two red coloured silicone rings, one thick and one thin and two black (nitrile rubber?) rings, again one thick and one thin.
When I installed the new AS idler I pretty much just selected one at random, which happened to be the thick black one.
So today I took the black o-ring off and replaced it with the thin red one and.... bingo! It was much quieter.
The red o-rings are quite a bit softer than the black ones and my hunch is that this is what's making the difference here. I may well be on my way to become an o-ring obsessive!
The original idler is a bit quieter than the AS idler with the thick black ring but I the AS idler with the thin red ring is better still.
The thick red o-ring and the thinner one are similar, so it appears that it could be the material that makes the difference and not the thickness of the o-ring. Of course the red rings could also be made to a tighter dimensional tolerance too but I haven't noticed anything that would suggest that to be the case.
I'm also going to investigate precision grinding the idler to see what gains can be had with that.