It is disingenuous to say criticisms of Starmer have been ‘invented’. Criticisms are quite genuine. If you believe that the party that campaigned against the
Labour Party for two general elections will offer what you voted for in those elections, that’s up to you. If you believe that a party that has shown itself to be institutionally racist and fundamentally democratic will offer an alternative to the racist and undemocratic Tories, that is up to you. If you believe that Labour can spend more on police, NHS, Schools, the environment, Care, infrastructure, and cut spending at the same time, again, that’s up to you, but the observation that Starmer’s Labour is pro Tory, racist, undemocratic, and economically illiterate is not invention, it is evidential, and as for being fundamentally undemocratic, it is felt by personal experience of being made unwelcome and disenfranchised in my own party for the sin of freezing my nuts off campaigning for a Labour victory in the winter of 2019