Marchbanks
Hat and Beard member
Having very much enjoyed a bottle of 2010 Ch Cissac recently, I’m tempted by the 2020 being offered by House of Townend at £96/dozen EP.
Probably the only US winemaker I could name, unless Francis Ford Coppola counts. Even then I’ve only just realised I spelled his name wrongly, putting the d after the wrong n. Reading between the lines of that obit he could obviously be a feisty chap. He (and by extension this thread) is responsible for six of the total of seven US bottles in the ancestral cellars, which are 2015 PN Isabelle. None tried as yet - is it too soon to open one in his honour?I read today that Jim Clendenen has died. The wine world has suddenly lost some of its colour.
https://www.sfchronicle.com/food/wi...anta-Barbara-vintner-who-changed-16183065.php
Resurrecting an old question, I opened a bottle of Ch. Musar Aana 2016 last night. I have had Ch. Musar 2001 (and I still have one bottle left).Do you have any details of the Aana, how different is it to the regular Ch. Musar?
I would say a bottle of 2015 Isabelle (named after his daughter) would be most fitting.
2015 Isabelle is wonderful stuff. A bottle today would be just the job.
Thanks for the advice. I'll move one to the Aldi cooler in readiness. Perhaps not today though, I will need to bulk up a bit first in order to lift one of those giant bottles.
Perhaps you can get one of those people you’re offering a hugging service to, to move it for you. Just choose a suitably strapping lass, or lad, once the hugging has been dealt with.Thanks for the advice. I'll move one to the Aldi cooler in readiness. Perhaps not today though, I will need to bulk up a bit first in order to lift one of those giant bottles.
I think that was Ronsay, not rosé... anyway, it will go in the 15C section, not the 10C section with the rosé. Oh yes, it’s a dual temperature job (remember it came from Aldi, it’s not just any old tat.)Put it next to your Kylie Minogue rosé.
RIPI read today that Jim Clendenen has died. The wine world has suddenly lost some of its colour.
https://www.sfchronicle.com/food/wi...anta-Barbara-vintner-who-changed-16183065.php
Same here mbe, although Jancis says PN is notI was quite tempted to buy one just to see what you're all talking about, but it's too expensive for me. And I was put off by a comment on the Majestic website which said that it tastes big time of new oak. If I ever see it for sale in a bar or restaurant I'll try it.
I wouldn’t pay Majestic’s list price either. But according to CT I paid £37, which while still a lot in my book makes it at least a possibility.I was quite tempted to buy one just to see what you're all talking about, but it's too expensive for me. And I was put off by a comment on the Majestic website which said that it tastes big time of new oak. If I ever see it for sale in a bar or restaurant I'll try it.
That label style looks familiar. Looking in my cellar book (OK - my Excel spreadsheet) I see a positive note from Nov.2016 for Au Bon Climat Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir, Central Coast, USA 2012; and another good note from May.2017 for Au Bon Climat Santa Maria Valley pinot noir "La Bauge Au-dessus" 2012.
So there it was - RIP Jim.
I enjoyed it very much. Much more than that I shouldn’t say as an extreme PN novice (this was only the fourth bottle I can ever remember opening.) - I’ll leave the in depth qualitative analysis to those better qualified. But it certainly had all those PN things I read about - heady bouquet, pale colour, delicate but alluring taste. Definitely a lot better than a NZ one (admittedly less than half the price) that I had recently. I’ll be keeping my eyes open for another 25% off everything sale at Majestic in order to get some more. ...