As mentioned by another member, this month's HiFi Choice compared the Majik LP12, P10, SL-1200G and a couple of others.
Couple of comments I thought were relevant to your quest...
Majik LP12
"It does most of the good things that all the other contenders do, but tends to push the emotional element of the song that little bit further. Paul McCartney's voice seems more expressive than the rest, and the bass guitar and piano work evoke a more profound sense of mood. With the technics for example, listening to it is a dazzling hi-fi experience, whereas with the Linn - which is clearly inferior in terms of fine detail resolution - it somehow manages to sound more poignant."
"For such an old design, the new Majik LP12 sounds surprisingly modern. It's nowhere near as soft and rounded as it used to be, but still retains just enough of the traditional Sondek character for it to charm listeners. The result is a big, confident and enjoyable sound that's tonally still a little on the warm side."
P10
"This makes it an enjoyable listen, but some might think it a little too analytical."
"It's not a turntable that makes everything sound fat, sweet and warm - that's for sure. This results in both good and bad consequences; the Elgar is a vibrant listen with lots of lovely spatial and timing information. It gives an intricate and quite intense rendition. Yet with the Lou Donaldson track, it doesn't groove quite as well as the Linn, Origin Live and Technics."