Advertisement



  1. Things you need to know about the new ‘Conversations’ PM system:

    a) DO NOT REPLY TO THE NOTIFICATION EMAIL! I get them, not the intended recipient. I get a lot of them and I do not want them! It is just a notification, log into the site and reply from there.

    b) To delete old conversations use the ‘Leave conversation’ option. This is just delete by another name.
    Dismiss Notice

ATC SCM-20 SL Passive Towers

Discussion in 'audio' started by antonio1, Mar 18, 2017.

  1. antonio1

    antonio1 pfm Member

    Any opinions?
     
  2. hifi-dog

    hifi-dog pfm Member

    Always gonna be good if you're in to ATC . It's still a 20 just on its own plinth
     
  3. antonio1

    antonio1 pfm Member

    Wasn't around 3K £ as long as 5 years ago and 5K now?
     
  4. doctorf

    doctorf left footed right winger

    I had the active version before my 50s and I liked them.
    They were a bit bass light and, horror of horrors, I used a sub with them but they did sound very good!
     
  5. Mare

    Mare Member

    ATC is bass light IMO...
    Had a chance to listen to SCM11, SCM19 and SCM40...
    Not my cup of tea without subs...
    Nice treble and mid.
     
  6. Purité Audio

    Purité Audio Trade: Purite Audio

    What does that mean exactly, that the speakers don't measure as specified?
    Keith
     
  7. Whaleblue

    Whaleblue Southbound

    Umm, ATC is bass light?

    You've not heard 50s, 100s... then!
     
  8. AndyU

    AndyU pfm Member

    If there's any chance you can go active you'll possibly get a better result from the SCM19As. But all the ATC speakers I have heard or owned are superb, with a particularly wonderful midrange. The bass doesnt go THUMP THUMP THUMP though, and the treble doesn't go TTTSSSSZZZING so if you are used to hifi you need to recalibrate.
     
  9. hifi-dog

    hifi-dog pfm Member

    Agree with above!
     
  10. MattSPL

    MattSPL pfm Member

    ATC's are tuned to have a flat frequency response, whereas most other speakers have a bass hump, usually around the port tuning frequency. This can make 'other' speakers, even small ones sound larger than they ought to and on the other hand, is why some people think ATC's sound bass light.

    I've just added an EQ to my speakers to cut some nasty bass peaks measured in my room, some caused by the room itself and one I suspect is the transmission line tuning frequency.
    I got the response almost flat in the sub 100hz region and guess what, my speakers now sound very like a pair of ATC's.
     
  11. mattgbell

    mattgbell Help the elderly and unwell!

    I had the SCM40s on home demo for a fortnight recently. That was followed by a home demo of the new JBL 4429s. The bass performance of the JBLs was so much better than the ATCs: flatter, more accurate, more textured.

    Having said that, the ATCs' midrange was massively better than the rather honky JBLs.

    I'm sure the bigger ATCs would give the JBLs a run for their money in the bass department.

    My point is that a given ATC model may be engineered to be flat within its FR envelope, but its FR envelope may be a long way short of full range. And if you want full range, it may work out quite expensive.
     
  12. MattSPL

    MattSPL pfm Member

    Yes your right about the somewhat limited frequency response, but we are dealing with 7" or smaller bass drivers in the ATC's, unless you go bigger with the 50's and above.
    Those JBL's use a 12inch driver, so I'd expect them to be better in the bass.
     
  13. adamdea

    adamdea You are not a sound quality evaluation device

    So was it the linters frequency range of the ATCs you didn't like or was the quality lacking even within its range?
     
  14. mattgbell

    mattgbell Help the elderly and unwell!

    The former, I guess. But subjectively all sorts of things are happening that are only poorly conveyed by the statement that their FR is limited.
     
  15. antonio1

    antonio1 pfm Member

    whaaaat? ATC bass integrates seamlessly.
    I adore the way it does it.
    Though they don't not go over the stated FR.
    Do the 20s go lesser in that regard to 19s?
    Not that its bad in itself I even like the 11s.
     
  16. TLS

    TLS pfm Member

    The ATC's midrange driver is considered as one of the best there is so no surprise. The JBL's are $2,000/pair less expensive than the SCM40's. You can even find 4429's for $1625 each which is about £1300 each.
     

Share This Page





Advertisement


  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice