A couple of Mahler symphonies.
First, Rattle and the LSO in the second symphony, at the Proms earlier this week. I had high expectations, and was disappointed with what I thought was quite a sloppy performance, with some of the important phrases being rushed, and with annoying ‘detail’ in unusual places. Not one to return to, unfortunately. Was anyone at the concert, and came away with a different view?
On to the seventh yesterday evening, with Petrenko and the Berlin Philharmonic. An excellent performance in my view, with a coherent structure throughout that brought all the disparate movements together compellingly. The relationship between the guitar and the orchestra in the fourth movement was particularly effective. Definitely one to listen to again and to compare against some of my reference versions.